Compact cars have come a long way in America. Originally relegated to ‘econobox’ status, today compacts have dramatically improved build quality and make up a sizable portion of the market. Here are our picks:
2010 Honda Civic

The Civic is the classic compact car. Excellent gas mileage, basic amenities, and decent looks. The one drawback? Its engine is relatively underpowered…you may not feel as confident getting onto a highway with a Civic as you would in other cars. That’s the trade-off for getting 37 miles per gallon.
2010 Mazda 3

The Mazda3 is a great little car with much, much better handling than other compacts. It’s safe, sporty, and you can add lots of options (like leather, Bose sound, etc.) to give it features not normally found in cars of this class. Unfortunately, the new design with its smiley faced grill is…divisive, to say the least.
2010 Ford Focus

In recent decades, the Japanese have dominated the compact car market with their affordable, reliable vehicles that consumers loved. Ford, however, has dramatically improved reliability and function in the past few years, and the new Ford Focus is the result of that. Catering to the Gen X/Gen Y demographic, you can get the new Focus with a Pet Package, a Sports Package, an Express Yourself Package (groan), a Friends Package, and the Professional Package, thus continuing the long history of American carmakers to offer insane amount of options and packages. We like the Focus though, it’s a great little car.
2010 Toyota Corolla

If you’ve been to a mall parking lot, you’ve seen the Toyota Corolla. Worldwide, one Corolla is sold about every 40 seconds. Now in its tenth generation, the Corolla is a ubiquitous compact noted for its safety. You can’t go wrong with this incredibly reliable compact.
Our Pick
It’s a tough call because these are all solid, reliable vehicles, but we have to choose the Civic, with the Focus coming in second. The Civic and Focus represent the best compromise between the other cars (Mazda3 for performance, Corolla for safety), however we prefer the design of the Civic and Honda’s reputation for reliability.